Skip to content
Hollywood Standard

Oscars

Seyfried Ruled Out of Globes, BAFTA and Actor Awards Acting Races; Oscar Ruling Pending

Amanda Seyfried's performance in the documentary You Can See Everything has been ruled out of three major acting races, while the Academy's actors branch has yet to decide.

Front of the Kodak Theatre complex on a sunny day, with cars and pedestrians on the street below

Amanda Seyfried has been ruled ineligible for acting nominations at the Golden Globes, the BAFTAs and the Actor Awards for her work in the documentary You Can See Everything, according to a Hollywood Reporter report dated Nov. 12. The Critics Choice Awards approved her for Best Supporting Actress consideration.

The Academy has not issued a formal ruling on her Oscar eligibility. As of Nov. 14, formal eligibility determinations are expected in early December.

Three Awards Bodies Close the Door on Acting Nominations

You Can See Everything, directed by Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim, opened in U.S. theaters on Oct. 16. Seyfried appears in it as herself and also plays a real-life figure in reenactments, for which she is credited under that character's name, according to Next Best Picture.

The Hollywood Reporter report gives each body's reason. The Golden Globes exclude documentaries from their motion-picture categories, with an exception for Cinematic and Box Office Achievement, and a docudrama with more than 25% documentary footage or audio is treated as a documentary. BAFTA's guidance tells films entered in its documentary category to stay out of the acting categories. The Actor Awards require scripted features and expressly exclude documentaries.

The report adds that Nov. 12 was the final general-entry submission deadline for acting awards.

The Academy's Rules Leave the Question to a Committee

The Academy's rules permit documentary features to compete in other categories if they meet the relevant requirements and deadlines, the Hollywood Reporter report says. Acting eligibility questions go to the Actors Branch Executive Committee.

Next Best Picture, in an article published Oct. 21, cited the rules' requirement that roles be credited in the film's legal billing and demonstrably performed by humans with their consent. It called the committee's authority over eligibility the main obstacle, and judged Seyfried most likely eligible but only a "strong maybe" as a nominee. It noted that her most praised scenes show her as herself, which it said could lead the committee to find her ineligible.

The Hollywood Reporter said representatives of the committee have given A24, the film's distributor, informal assurances that there is no apparent reason to exclude her. Her eligibility for the Academy Awards remains undecided.

A24 Is Said to Focus on the Oscars

SAG-AFTRA encouraged A24 to appeal the Actor Awards decision, according to the Hollywood Reporter. Sources told the publication that the studio plans to concentrate on the Oscars, and a formal appeal would not be forthcoming.

Next Best Picture reported that A24's campaign covers Best Picture, Best Director, Film Editing, Cinematography and Best Supporting Actress, beyond Best Documentary Feature. The same article noted that no documentary has been nominated for Best Picture in the Academy's 99 years.

Seyfried had previously won an Emmy for playing the same real-life figure in Hulu's The Dropout. The Hollywood Reporter report also says she won a Golden Globe and a Critics Choice award for that role in 2023.

“The Academy has not issued a formal ruling on her Oscar eligibility.”

The Directing Race Is Closed Too

Slashfilm reported on Oct. 28 that You Can See Everything cannot compete for the Directors Guild of America's Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Theatrical Feature Film, because documentaries are ineligible for that award. Slashfilm attributed the decision to a Variety report. The film can compete in the guild's documentary directing category.

Slashfilm noted, citing Variety, that the DGA award is typically considered a bellwether for the Best Director winner, and that the DGA winner has gone on to win Best Director in all but eight occasions.

What Happens Next

The Academy's formal eligibility determinations are expected in early December, according to the Hollywood Reporter. Oscar nominations are scheduled for Jan. 21, 2027, and the ceremony for March 14, 2027.

Seyfried said of campaigning, per the Hollywood Reporter, "Now that they're going to let me loose and show up, I'm down!" The report also says Fielder has stated that she received no scripts in advance and had no approval over the footage.

More in Awards