Skip to content
Hollywood Standard

Music Royalties

Amazon's 13.4 Percent Offer Widens the Gap Over Songwriter Royalties for 2028 to 2032

Four services want to keep the 15.35 percent headline rate for 2028 to 2032. Amazon proposes 13.4 percent, and publishers seek a higher formula.

Rows of vinyl records standing upright on tall wooden shelves along a narrow room with a pink floor

Streaming services pay songwriters and music publishers mechanical royalties. The rates are set through the U.S. Copyright Royalty Board, which accepted the current settlement in December 2022. That deal, Phonorecords IV, covers 2023 through 2027.

In October 2026, the parties filed their proposals for the next five years, Phonorecords V, which would begin on January 1, 2028. The filings show a wide gap. Four services want the 15.35 percent headline rate kept for 2028 through 2032, while Amazon proposes 13.4 percent. The copyright owners, the NMPA and NSAI, want a higher rate under a different formula.

What the Current Phonorecords IV Deal Sets

Under the current deal, the headline rate is a percentage of a service's U.S. revenue. It starts at 15.1 percent in 2023 and rises to 15.35 percent in 2027. The rate for 2026 is 15.3 percent, according to both Music Business Worldwide and American Songwriter.

The calculation differs for standalone subscriptions and bundles. For standalone plans, a service pays the higher of the headline rate or the lower of 26.2 percent of total content costs or $1.10 per subscriber, with a 60-cent minimum per subscriber. Bundles pay 24.5 percent of total content costs, with a floor of 33 cents per active subscriber.

The Copyright Royalty Board set the previous round, Phonorecords III, which covered 2018 to 2022. The headline rate rose from 10.5 percent to 15.1 percent, phased in from 11.4 percent in 2018. On remand in 2022, the board reaffirmed 15.1 percent.

Apple says the 2022 settlement raised total-content-cost rates, per-subscriber minimums and floors on its subscriptions by 16.67 to 37.5 percent compared with Phonorecords III, and the headline rate by 0.25 points.

The October 2026 Filing Deadline and Participants

The Copyright Royalty Board's deadline for non-settling participants to file was October 5, 2026. The National Music Publishers' Association and the Nashville Songwriters Association International filed jointly as the copyright owners. Services including Amazon, Apple, Pandora, Spotify and Google filed as participants, alongside the three major record companies and A2IM. Other participants include the Songwriters Guild of America, Word Collections, Eight Mile Music Companies, the Music Artists Coalition and the songwriter George Johnson.

The Digital Media Association, the trade body for US streaming services, issued a statement on October 6 that hoped for a timely resolution and did not refer to any specific rate. Its CEO, Graham Davies, cited NMPA data showing US publishing revenue grew more than 30 percent. Public redacted versions of the filings followed on October 7.

Using NMPA data, the Digital Media Association puts publishing revenue growth above 30 percent, from $5.6 billion in 2022 to $7.3 billion in 2025. The NMPA reports that the 2025 figure was up about 3.7 percent on the year. Apple gives the same $7.3 billion figure for 2025 and says it is about $1.69 billion more than in 2022.

Where Services, Amazon and Publishers Stand

Spotify, Google, Pandora and Apple want the 2027 terms carried forward for 2028 to 2032, including the 15.35 percent headline rate. Spotify proposes no other changes. Apple's filing says a reduced bundle rate was “absolutely essential” to Apple agreeing to the settlement's rate increases. Craig McFadden of SiriusXM says nothing has changed at Pandora's on-demand services that would warrant an increase.

Google proposes a new allocation rule so that rates apply only to the share of plays a license covers. It also excludes app store commissions, carrier-billing charges, partner fees and certain taxes from royalty revenue. Pandora seeks four smaller changes, including reciprocal late fees on overpayments and excluding app store commissions.

Amazon proposes a 13.4 percent headline rate for services outside bundles, down from 15.35 percent. Its total-content-cost rate would fall from 26.2 to 22.8 percent, and its standalone per-subscriber amount from $1.10 to 96 cents. For bundles, it would pay 21.3 percent of total content costs, down from 24.5 percent. Amazon's economist, Leslie Marx of Duke University, estimates the rates would be about 13 percent below Phonorecords IV levels.

The NMPA and NSAI propose that services pay the greatest of 20 percent of service revenue, 40 percent of total content costs, $2.40 per subscriber per month, or $0.004 per play. The $2.40 figure is 20 percent of a $12 subscription price. They also want per-play rates to apply to free, ad-supported services.

Sony Music Publishing's Greg Prata says 15.3 percent yields about $1.99 a month in total royalties on Spotify's $12.99 subscription. NMPA CEO David Israelite said songwriters should receive at least 40 percent of what labels and artists get.

A group of songwriter and publisher participants backs a flat rate of $0.0030 per interactive stream in 2028, adjusted for inflation in later years. Among the backers are the Songwriters Guild of America, Word Collections, Eight Mile and George Johnson. The Society of Composers & Lyricists and Music Creators North America also support it.

Inflation and Bundling Drive the Dispute

The publishers support annual inflation adjustments for per-subscriber and per-play rates. Spotify and Apple oppose them. Spotify's economist, Steven R. Peterson, cites about 13 percent U.S. inflation from June 2022 to June 2026 and says the Phonorecords IV agreement is the right benchmark, with no need for adjustments.

Bundling is the second main fight. Spotify reclassified its U.S. Premium tiers as audiobook bundles in March 2024, and Amazon followed in November 2024. The Spotify tiers were reclassified as bundles that include 15 hours of audiobook listening a month. The publishers want tighter bundling rules. Spotify's senior legal counsel, Sara Domeier, argues that changing central terms would require rebalancing the rest of the deal.

The Mechanical Licensing Collective (MLC) sued Spotify in 2024, and Judge Analisa Torres dismissed the original claims in January 2025. One Music Business Worldwide report gives March 2025 as the date the case was reopened, and another gives September 2025. On September 1, 2026, Torres denied the MLC's request for an immediate appeal but struck Spotify's unclean hands defense. The case is ongoing.

Publishers say Spotify has taken more than $500 million in mechanical royalties that should have been paid to songwriters and publishers. The NMPA puts the cost of bundling to songwriters and publishers at almost $480 million since 2024, based on Spotify's own estimates. It says bundling has cut royalties at Spotify and Amazon by around 30 percent, and projects the cost could exceed $3.1 billion through 2032 if not reversed.

Spotify's latest quarterly filing estimates its liability for March 2024 to June 2026 at about €473 million if the MLC were entirely successful, plus potential penalties and interest. That figure is partly offset by direct US publishing deals Spotify has signed since January 2025 with Universal Music Publishing Group, Warner Chappell, Kobalt, Sony Music Publishing and BMG.

“Four services want the 15.35 percent headline rate kept for 2028 through 2032, while Amazon proposes 13.4 percent.”

The Schedule Runs Through December 2027

The Copyright Royalty Board issued a revised case schedule on October 2, 2026. Amended written direct statements are due December 21, 2026, and responses to other parties' cases are due February 1, 2027. The NMPA and NSAI have asked the board for a subpoena for documents from the MLC litigation, which Spotify opposes.

A settlement window runs from January 25 to February 15, 2027. If the case does not settle, the hearing is set for March 22 to April 15, 2027. The judges' initial decision is due December 17, 2027.

Physical and Download Rates Follow a Separate Track

Physical formats and permanent downloads run under a separate statute. American Songwriter gives the 2026 rate for those formats as 13.1 cents per work, up from 12.7 cents in 2025, and 2.52 cents per minute for songs longer than five minutes. Music Business Worldwide gives the 2026 rate as 13.1 cents per song or 2.52 cents per minute, whichever is larger.

A proposed settlement filed in June by the three major labels, A2IM, the NMPA, NSAI and the Music Artists Coalition would keep the current structure through 2032 with inflation adjustments. The Songwriters Guild of America, Word Collections, Eight Mile and George Johnson objected to it, and the Society of Composers & Lyricists raised conflict-of-interest concerns. The record companies and A2IM project about 13.7 cents in 2028. The Copyright Royalty Board has not yet decided whether to adopt the deal.

More in Culture